24/7 Free DUI Help 413-731-9995

Blog

OUI Blood Draws and Implied Consent

Posted by Joseph Bernard | Aug 08, 2017 | 0 Comments

In many OUI cases involving accidents, citizens have been taken to the hospital where their blood was improperly taken at the request of a police officer. Because it often not possible for an officer to perform field sobriety tests or request a breath test in a case involving an accident, an officer may follow a citizen to the hospital to obtain a blood sample. The blood sample will then be analyzed to determine the citizen's blood alcohol content which may be used as evidence of impairment.

A blood draw is “an invasion of bodily integrity implicates an individual's ‘most personal and deep-rooted expectations of privacy'" which implicates a citizen's Fourth Amendment rights. Recently, two decisions have been issued by the Supreme Court of the United States, Birchfield v. North Dakota and Missouri v. McNeely, that emphasize that a citizen has a reasonable expectation of privacy in their blood. The Court also emphasized that absent consent or exigent circumstances, an officer is required to obtain a warrant before obtaining a blood sample from a citizen.

The Court in Birchfield also discussed Implied Consent Laws. Massachusetts has an Implied Consent Law which states that anyone who operates a motor vehicle in Massachusetts “shall be deemed to have consented to submit to a chemical test or analysis of his breath or blood in the event that he is arrested for operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of intoxicating liquor…” This means that by driving a motor vehicle in Massachusetts, you are stating that if you are arrested for OUI, you consent to a breath or blood test to determine your blood alcohol concentration.

However, the Court in Birchfield explained that while a citizen may give implied consent to a blood draw, actual consent is still required to obtain the sample. In other words, an officer cannot simply obtain a blood sample from a citizen based solely on Massachusetts' Implied Consent Law. Rather, the officer must explain to the citizen that they are requesting a sample of their blood and the citizen must then indicate to the officer that they actually consent to a blood draw. The Court further stated that a citizen may withdraw their implied consent and refuse to provide a blood sample. If a citizen refuses to provide a blood sample, an officer may then obtain a warrant.

In Massachusetts, officers have routinely failed to obtain blood samples properly. In order to give valid consent to a warrantless blood draw, a citizen must give knowing and voluntary consent. This means that a citizen must have knowledge and understanding of exactly what it is that they are consenting to -- a blood draw. Typically an officer will read a Statutory Rights and Consent form to a citizen to obtain a blood sample. This form is most commonly used to obtain consent from a citizen to submit to a breath test, and does not explain in any way that an officer is requesting a blood sample. It only generally states that the officer is “requesting that you submit to a chemical test to determine your blood alcohol concentration.” But what does this mean? The average person does not know what a chemical test is or that there are multiple kinds of chemical tests to determine a blood alcohol concentration, let alone which test the officer is requesting. Therefore, citizen cannot give a knowing and voluntary consent based solely on this form. Yet officers routinely rely on this form alone to obtain a blood sample.

To learn more about information about whether the blood draw in your matter was properly obtained, contact Attorney Joseph D. Bernard at 413-731-9995.

About the Author

Joseph Bernard

Joseph Bernard has practiced in Hampden County, Springfield Massachusetts for over 20 years and reside in Belchertown, Massachusetts.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Fight to protect your future

If found guilty, you may be facing serious penalties and life altering consequences, including jail time, steep fines, court ordered alcohol treatment programs, and community service. In addition, your driver’s license can be suspended for an extended period of time. Depending on the specific circumstances pertaining to your case, your offense may be charged as a felony, which exponentially increases your penalties. Do not sit back and wait for your charges to resolve themselves. Be proactive and call immediately to secure the representation of Attorney Joseph Bernard to resolve your case in the most efficient way possible and with the most favorable outcome available to you.

Locations

Palmer Office

1012 Pleasant St
Palmer, MA 01069
413-283-8445

Springfield Office

1 Monarch Pl Suite 1100
Springfield, MA 01144
413-731-9995

Belchertown Office

5 Jabish St
Belchertown, MA 01007
413-323-6556

Northampton Office

4 Market Street
Northampton, MA 01060
413-731-9995

Menu